🥃 I thought I was sipping Pappy... until I saw the $75 price tag

💥 Opening Pour

It started with a glass by the fire and a pour from an unlabeled bottle. I assumed it was Pappy. It wasn’t.
Turns out, you don’t always need to drop big bucks for a bottle that drinks like a legend.

📖 The Story

It was a chilly October evening — you know the kind. Leaves crunching under boots, smoke curling from the fire pit, the world tasting like fall.

Chuck handed me a glass and said nothing. That was his tell — when he wants me to taste something without bias, he goes silent. No label, no hint. Just “here, sip this.”

First sniff: toasted oak, cinnamon, rich caramel.
Sip: full-bodied, velvety heat, waves of spice and orchard fruit.
The finish lingered like a ghost story around a campfire — all leather, clove, and black pepper.

I swore it had to be a unicorn.
“Pappy?” I asked.

He just laughed and handed me the bottle:
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof. Batch A125. About $75.
I almost dropped my glass.

That pour taught me a lesson: there’s a line where price stops mattering, and flavor takes over.

These five bottles are exactly that. They taste like triple-digit pours, but you’ll find ‘em under $80 — if you know what to look for.

🥇 The Weekly Pour - 5 Today

Bottle: Elijah Craig Barrel Proof – Batch A125
Price: ~$75
Proof: 125.6
Age: 10 years, 7 months
Nose: Vanilla bean, toasted oak, orchard fruit
Palate: Spicy caramel, cherry, clove, nutmeg
Finish: Long, leathery, and heat-kissed

✅ Barrel strength, no water added
✅ Legit decade+ age statement
✅ Drinks like prestige without the price

🛒 Buy it now → thebarreltap - $74.99

Bottle: Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style
Price: ~$60
Proof: 115
Age: NAS (tastes like 8–10 years)
Nose: Burnt sugar, chocolate, roasted pecans
Palate: Cherry cola, cinnamon, maple
Finish: Toasted oak, graham cracker, dark smoke

✅ Decadent dessert profile
✅ High proof without the harsh bite
✅ Perfect for fall sipping or fireside cocktails

🛒 Buy it now → Frootbat.com - $59.99

Bottle: W.L. Weller Antique 107
Price: ~$60 (MSRP)
Proof: 107
Age: ~6–7 years
Nose: Caramel apple, spice cake, oak
Palate: Orchard fruit, vanilla, cinnamon
Finish: Peppery warmth, fading into sweet leather

✅ Wheated mash bill = smooth power
✅ Often called “baby Pappy”
✅ Big flavor, reasonable price (if you find it at MSRP)

🛒 Buy it now → Craft Spirit Shop - $169.99 (decent secondary market price)

Bottle: Four Roses Single Barrel (OBSF)
Price: ~$60
Proof: 100
Age: ~7–9 years
Nose: Vanilla cream, orange peel, floral rye
Palate: Cherry cola, brown sugar, baking spice
Finish: Citrus brightness, lingering oak

✅ High-rye zing with balanced sweetness
✅ Single barrel = unique bottle every time
✅ Under-the-radar collector’s darling

🛒 Buy it now → Craft Spirit Shop - $54.99

Bottle: Elijah Craig Barrel Proof – Batch C924
Price: ~$75
Proof: 132.8
Age: 11 years
Nose: Brown sugar, baked apple, toasted oak
Palate: Rich caramel, cinnamon, clove, dark fruit
Finish: Warm, long, layered with sweet heat

✅ Barrel strength bourbon that drinks bold and balanced
✅ 11-year age adds depth and structure
✅ Fall-in-a-glass flavor profile at a steal of a price

🛒 Buy it now → Sip Whiskey - $74.99

🍹The Art of Mixing

🍁 Bourbon Apple Smash

Ingredients

• 2 oz Four Roses Single Barrel

• ½ oz lemon juice

• ½ oz fresh apple cider

• ¼ oz maple syrup

• 2 dashes Angostura bitters

• Garnish: apple slice + cinnamon stick

Instructions

1. Shake everything with ice

2. Strain over fresh rocks

3. Garnish and serve chilled

Tip: Serve with a cinnamon-sugar rim for bonus points.

🍖 Flavor Pairing Picks

Pair it with:

🍗 Smoked Pork Loin — The bourbon’s spice cuts through the fat, while the smoke complements charred barrel notes.

🍑 Peach Cobbler — Bright fruit meets caramel and baking spice in the glass. Dessert never had it this good.

💨 My Father La Opulencia — Bold and earthy cigar that mirrors deep oak and chocolate in these bourbons.

🧠 Big Lesson of the Week

Bourbon’s “worth” isn’t about the price tag. It’s about proof, barrel choice, and balance. These five bottles sip like a celebration — even if you only paid $60.)

🥂 Final Toast

To the bottles that taste rare, cost reasonable, and remind us why we fell in love with bourbon in the first place.

🥃 Repeatable Proverb

“The oak’s respect isn’t bought with price, but earned in flame and time.”

🚀 Unlock the Full Pour Experience

You’re reading the Free Edition of Art of the Pour.
Upgrade to The Bourbon Society for:

• 📦 Four Exclusive Collector’s-Edition Quarterly Issues (Mailed To Your Home)

• 🥃 “Neat Notes” Monthly Whiskey Dispatch (Digital-Only Bonus)

• 🗺️ Exclusive Collectible Maps & Charts

• 🎟️ Premium Member Perks & Discounts

• ✅ Guarantee of Satisfaction — Cancel any time for full refund on all unmailed issues

👉 Upgrade Now

Now Its Your Turn

💬 Ever been fooled by a “cheap” bottle that sipped like royalty?
📥 Drop me your favorite under-$80 sleeper in the comments.
📌 Save this for your next bottle run.
📤 Share with a buddy still chasing Pappy.

Cheers to fireside sips, surprise bottles, and bourbon that punches above its price,

Ethan “Neat” Whitmore

P.S. Next week, I’ll show you 3 incredible bottles you shouldn’t open unless you’re ready to share. Trust me — once people taste them, they’ll never forget.